A KINGSTON Council meeting called to discuss the construction of urgently needed basketball facilities broke down within a minute last week, and ended without a final decision.
The 9 November meeting was called on short notice to discuss offering in-principle support for a proposed indoor stadium at the Kennedy Community Centre in Dingley Village with at least four indoor courts. The 45 minute meeting featured numerous points of order, a dissent motion against the mayor, and roughly 20 minutes of debate on the actual proposal before the matter was deferred to council’s next ordinary meeting scheduled for 23 November.
The proposal would see Kingston Council work in partnership with Hawthorn Football Club, the Kennedy Community Centre tenant, to gather support from other levels of government for the project. The St Kilda Football Club, based out of Linton Street in Moorabbin, has also reportedly declared interest in building an indoor stadium of its own.
The lack of decision leaves the Dingley Village basketball stadium proposal in limbo, with just five days between the date of Kingston Council’s next scheduled meeting and the state election.
In her final meeting as mayor, Cr Georgina Oxey spoke strongly against the deferral. She said “we are weeks away from a state election. A number of the conversations that we’ve had indicate that there is a project that has a business case, there is a project that has two years plus of planning that’s gone into it, that has planning permits, that has the approvals required in order to go ahead with a project, that has indications that this is something that is potentially going to receive funding should council even just write a letter of support for the project.”
“The other proposal that is potentially in front of us has no business case, has no ask on the table of Kingston Council, does not have planning permission, does not even have a letter of support from Kingston Council [for a project] that is potentially to be built on Kingston Council land on Linton Street,” Cr Oxley said. “As far as the deferral goes, and as far as the idea that we are going to continue to need more time, at some point as councillors we’re going to need to make a decision.”
Cr Sarah O’Donnell, also speaking strongly against the deferral, told the meeting that a letter of intent would be a non-binding reflection of council’s current position.
“This does not stop exploring other options, including St Kilda,” Cr O’Donnell said.
Cr Tony Athanasopoulos called for the deferral, after raising a point of order just 30 seconds into the evening arguing that not enough notice had been given prior to the scheduling of the meeting. He acknowledged that “by not deferring, it would give security to those out there that want to put money towards the project that’s before us”, but went on to say “if we want to call a special council meeting into the future so that we can hear a matter like this, we would do it correctly.”
The deferral was approved with the support of Crs Athanasopoulos, Chris Howe, Nikki Kaur, Kirralee Ashworth-Collett, Chris Hill, and Hadi Saab.
Cr Athanasopoulos’s point of order at the beginning of the 9 November meeting argued that the governance rules for scheduling a council meeting had not been followed. He said that “notice and agenda for all council meetings are to reach every councillor at least 48 hours before every meeting”, and argued that the matter did not meet the threshold for an extraordinary circumstance.
Meeting chair Cr Oxley ruled against the point of order, and a motion of dissent was swiftly raised against her. The dissent motion was narrowly upheld with the support of Crs Athanasopoulos, Howe, Kaur, Ashworth-Collett, Hill, and Saab.
Nearly 30 minutes passed between the start of the meeting and the beginning of debate on the sole item on the agenda.
The ultimately deferred motion called for council “to promptly prepare and issue a formal, non-binding letter of intent and in-principle support to Hawthorn Football Club, which may be provided to the Victorian and Australian Governments and other relevant funding stakeholders, confirming council’s strong support, in principle, for the proposed community indoor stadium and recognition of its strategic importance to Kingston; [and] council’s support for Hawthorn Football Club seeking and securing funding commitments from the Victorian and Australian Governments to progress the project.”
The proposed Dingley Village stadium comprised a minimum of four indoor courts, with the potential for expansion to six courts. The deferred motion read that “the project represents a significant opportunity to address an identified and longstanding community infrastructure need and is the proposal that is furthest progressed at this time; the proposed development has the potential to deliver substantial and lasting community benefits, including increased access to indoor sporting opportunities; the proposed partnership presents an opportunity to leverage investment from Hawthorn Football Club and the Victorian and Australian Governments to deliver community infrastructure that would otherwise require significant Council investment; and council’s in-principle support is subject to confirmation of external funding, further negotiations and the satisfactory resolution of all financial, governance, operational and contractual arrangements.”
The motion outlined that “any decision to make a financial contribution, enter into a binding agreement or formally participate in the delivery or operation of the facility must be subject to a further report and express resolution of council, following appropriate financial, legal and governance due diligence.”
Hawthorn FC officially opened the Kennedy Community Centre in 2025. The $113 million project was completed with $15 million from the federal government for stage one works, $15 million from the state government, and $5 million from Kingston Council. (“Footy facility ‘belongs to community’ – PM” The News, 26/11/2025)
First published in the Chelsea Mordialloc Mentone News – 18 November 2026

